Dear Reader,
As Natalie Merchant suspected when she sang The Hateful Hate (link above) there was an austere underbelly to the Puritan story of Thanksgiving. The Puritans cancelled Christmas and used Thanksgiving to fast, rather than to feast. There are also extremely disturbing documents proclaiming a “thanksgiving” when the Puritans massacred the Pequot Nation. Evidence of other possible horrors, like cannibalism among the early settlers, have surfaced.
For some reason these historical facts, mostly about the Puritans, have overborne the story of Pilgrim multiculturalism that led to America’s general embrace of Thanksgiving as a day for rest and feasting. Amid the culture wars of modern times, Americans seem to have forgotten why Thanksgiving became celebrated, rather than mourned. Americans seem to have forgotten, for example, why Lydia Maria Child’s popular children’s poem Over the River and Through the Wood was about traveling to Grandmother’s house for a feast, not a fast.
Washington Irving’s seminal horror story Sleepy Hollow also used Thanksgiving as a backdrop to make his austere Puritan protagonist pop. Irving depicted Ichabod Crane living in a community of Americans who used Thanksgiving to drink pints of beer, to enjoy each other’s company, to flirt with the opposite sex, and to celebrate the harvest with feasting. In Ichabod’s America, Thanksgiving was celebrated — it was not the dreary, sexless, Puritanical affair Ichabod would probably have preferred.
The story of how Thanksgiving (1) came to be a feast day, and then (2) became nationalized in the years before the Civil War seems forgotten these days. There no way to disentangle these layers from each other, but I will go in order and do my best to separate the two stories from each other for examination. I will endeavor to tell both of these stories just in time for the holiday.
(1) Why Thanksgiving is a Feast-day Rather Than a Fast-day
The Puritans of Massachusetts Bay, who canceled Christmas, made Thanksgiving an austere day for starving oneself, massacred the Pequots, and hanged the Salem witches, were always in the minority of their fellow settlers. Their austerity was a reaction to several liberal experiments happening all around them. Some of these experiments were more innocent than others.
For example, many settlers would cross-dress on Christmas Day - a tradition called “mumming.” Others would feast to excess. Many others engaged in what the Puritans called “free love” practices, which included some forms of polygamy that mixed with religious cult behavior. Some towns, for example, were said to have worshiped men or women who they thought was god, and who took many sexual partners to themselves. As pro-sex as these movements could be, The Testament of Anne Lee notably shows how anti-sex they can also be.
Amid these towns and movements, Boston became under dispute when Roger Williams, Governor Henry Vane, and Anne Hutchinson advocated for a fundamental protection of religious liberty and free speech. Their movements were overridden to decimate the Pequots to claim their lands as a “thanksgiving.” Williams, Vane, and Hutchinson were largely banished along with their followers for opposing this genocide. These movements, which included Native American rights to property and religious liberty, were generally banished to Rhode Island by the grace and generosity of the Wampanoag Tribe that Roger Williams befriended in his time of need.
The Puritans, including John Cotton, John Winthrop, and John Mason, took over after trying and banishing Anne Hutchinson and her many followers. They cemented a culture of austerity that made Thanksgiving a fasting day, and cancelled Christmas, among other dismal things. They also preached a gospel of works, rather than free grace, which most protestant churches today would probably label a clear heresy.
All the towns in New England that experimented in separatist religion and free worship, including the minority who seized Boston, are rooted in the older colony of Plymouth. No records survive, but a legend persists that the Mayflower was blown off course and landed in Plymouth in the middle of a harsh winter. Suffering and cold, the Plymouth settlers allegedly managed to begin a settlement among Native American Tribes who did not murder them or start a war with them.
These Natives taught the Pilgrims how to grow corn, hunt Native animals, and how to cook Native plants, and by learning from the Natives, the Pilgrims of Plymouth survived. They began to celebrate Thanksgiving as a feast day to commemorate this bond of friendship for purposes of survival. Their descendants persisted and continued on long after the Puritan take-over of Boston, a newer town of English transplants. The Puritans of Boston haughtily contested the convivial origins of Thanksgiving, hoping to exclude the Natives from their churches and from salvation over the objections of Williams, Hutchinson, and Vane.
But again, this group of purist Puritans were in the minority. Their views came late, and were grafted upon a root of multiculturalism, cultural exchange, and mutual care for survival. Had the Puritans been the first to show up on Plymouth Rock they all would have probably died out because of their prideful inability to receive life-saving knowledge about Native foods from the Native peoples.
Centuries earlier, Vikings similarly discovered and departed from American shores, possibly for similar reasons. When the Vikings tried to colonize Greenland, they failed because they refused to learn how to eat fish from the Native Eskimos. When a harsh winter killed their cattle, the Vikings perished as well, while the Eskimos survived. Racism and bigotry is particularly self-destructive when it causes a group of people to choose death by starvation rather than establishing links of friendship with Native peoples that could feed a starving people.
Thanksgiving celebrates the choice of American ancestors to set aside bigotry and racism to choose life through links of friendship with Native Tribes. God saw fit, they say, to allow these Pilgrims to survive the winters of their settlement by the friendship they found with Native people. On Thanksgiving, we give thanks for the bountiful harvest which we have learned to reap by sharing knowledge, and by at least choosing to receive life-saving gifts from Native groups who do not speak English or worship the Christian God.
This legend of survival through natural friendship love with foreigners and Natives, is the reason why Thanksgiving is a feast-day. It is the origin, which the Puritans grafted their austerity in several failed attempts to remake it into a fast-day. Their failure is experienced on a yearly basis when we gather to feast with family, even now, in these particularly fraught times.
(2) How Thanksgiving Was Nationalized
At first, Thanksgiving was a New England holiday only. But a woman writer and editor of Godey’s Lady’s Book, Sarah Joseph Hale, made it her life’s mission to nationalize the Thanksgiving holiday. In the years leading up to the Civil War, Ms. Hale held feasts and celebrations where she advocated for a day when no one in the Republic would go hungry.
Eventually, her advocacy reached the ears of Abraham Lincoln who nationalized the holiday on October 3, 1863 in a strategic attempt to avoid Civil War. Ms. Hale opposed slavery, but believed that the best way forward was together. She noted in many places and times that Northerners and Southerners shared links of blood and friendship.
Thus, Thanksgiving is a holiday of Union. It celebrates the imperfect Union of the States at one proverbial feasting table. It emphasizes our similarities and common interests, and it calls us to love each other despite or differences.
Critically, Ms. Hale was a New Englander who knew the legends of the Pilgrims, as well as the faults of the Puritans. She saw in the legend of her ancestors parlay with the Natives to honor their common interests and common feelings, a blueprint for American Union. She staunchly championed Thanksgiving as an opposition to the Southern secession movement with the sentiment that if her English ancestors could reach out and find common ground with Native Americans, that Northerners could find a way forward with the South and vice versa.
Washington Irving added his weighty support, but the brunt of the movement for Thanksgiving was led by women allies of Ms. Hale. Lydia Maria Child, mentioned above, was among them. Later on, Katherine K. Davis helped solidify the holiday’s common place in the American home with music.
Conclusion: Thanksgiving Is A Holiday for Times of Division
Even if Thanksgiving were only an imagined history of multicultural cooperation and love, it became a real blueprint for Ms. Hale’s cause for the Union. The United States did not have to fall into a Civil War to end slavery. It could have ended the horrid practice peacefully, by statute and constitutional interpretation, and, where interpretation failed, by amendment.
In fact, most of the Southern Founders of the nation (including Washington, Jefferson, Madison, and Tucker) thought it was inevitable. The abolitionist among them, St. George Tucker, wisely roared back at the stuffy Northerners who authored the despicable Alien & Sedition Acts. An early advocate of universal abolition, Tucker cited the fact that in Eastern Virginia alone there were significantly more free Black Americans around the time of the American Revolution than the entire North combined.
So too, we find ourselves in a time when we need to reach out to the South and to anyone willing to help the nation survive. This is not a time for purism or perfection. America needs to remember the origins of Thanksgiving in the imperfection of a big table of food and drink, where there is such a bounty provided by nature through common interest and feeling that it will not matter if one of the dishes is burned or has too much salt.
Errors mar our common table. American history is replete with mistakes, which we are more aware of today than ever, it seems. But, perhaps, if we focus on the common enjoyment of one another there will be a day when no American goes hungry, and every person’s basic needs are met. That is the dream of Thanksgiving set by Ms. Hale as an example for the Union in each common American home.
This is the dream I want to share with you this holiday season. May you get get stuffed, and ensure that your neighbor get stuffed too. It is the meaning of the holiday, and it could ease tensions in the critical moments we are living through today.
Yours cordially,
Joshua J. Schroeder, Esq.


